Added: Oriana Cummingham - Date: 16.04.2022 03:37 - Views: 22320 - Clicks: 3671
Maricopa County prosecutors have lost what may have been their final chance to shield two young girls from a cross-examination by Chris Simcox, the former Minuteman accused of molesting them. The case, likely the first of its kind in Arizona, pits the constitutional rights of a defendant against those of the alleged victim, and has drawn national scrutiny from victims' and civil rights organizations.
Jury selection was underway Tuesday, and officials say opening arguments could start as early as Thursday. Phoenix police arrested Simcox, 54, in June , following allegations that he molested three young girls, including one in the shower and another after bribing her with candy. One of the girls is not listed as a victim, but will serve as a witness, officials said. Simcox had made a name for himself as the co-founder of the border-watch vigilante group Minuteman Civil Defense Corps, and for running a brief campaign to unseat Arizona U.
Senator John McCain. Simcox faces two charges of child molestation, three counts of sexual conduct with a minor and one count of furnishing obscene or harmful items to minors. Charges of sexual conduct with a minor carry a mandatory life sentence, with possibility of parole after 35 years in prison. Simcox cleared the next hurdle last week, when Padilla agreed the defendant could personally cross-examine the two girls, who are now 7 and 8.
The girls were 5 and 6 in , when the alleged abuse took place. State prosecutors argued this would be a clear violation of victims' rights, and took the issue to a three-judge panel in the Arizona Court of Appeals Monday. Prosecutors asked Judges Margaret H.
Downie, Patricia K. Norris and Randall M. Howe to review the case and delay the imminent trial. Their decision, issued the same day, delivered dual blows for prosecutors. The court would not order a stay, but would accept jurisdiction over the case, meaning the state cannot appeal to a higher court. Cobb said Simcox's pursuit should have presented a clear violation of Arizona's Victims' bill of rights. State law guarantees the accuser is to be "free from intimidation, harassment, or abuse throughout the criminal justice process.
Prosecutors argued there were other routes for cross-examination that would have been less traumatizing for the girls but still protected Simcox's right to question witnesses. His advisory counsel or the judge, they said, could read the questions instead.
Simcox disagreed, as he painstakingly explained in a , handwritten motion penned from Lower Buckeye Jail. Simcox said his advisory counsel should not be "thrust" into a potential claim of ineffective assistance. Cobb said prosecutors don't know of another Arizona case that presented the same set of circumstances: a sex-crime case with accuser and a defendant representing themselves.
Judges have ruled both ways in cases around the country—in favor and against defendants who tried to question their accusers, said Meg Garvin, executive director of the National Crime Victim Law Institute at Lewis and Clark College in Portland. The center has offered to assist state prosecutors in Simcox's case. Garvin said defendants may attempt to conduct their own cross-examinations as a means to further intimidate or manipulate the alleged victims.
One of the more poignant examples of this, Garvin noted, was in Seattle in November, A year-old woman climbed to the roof of the story King County Courthouse and threatened to jump—an alternative preferable to facing her alleged abuser's line of questioning in court. The woman didn't jump and also didn't testify.
But others did, and defendant Salvador Aleman Cruz was convicted. Garvin said judges may be nervous about imposing limits on self-representation, and fear they're setting up an "appealable moment. Facebook Twitter . Ex-Minuteman likely to question girls in sex-abuse trial. Megan Cassidy The Republic azcentral. Share your feedback to help improve our site!Phoenix girls for sex
email: [email protected] - phone:(197) 425-7516 x 9486
Single Phoenix Girls Interested In African Sex Dating